Comprehensive  Ghana Oil and Gas news, information, updates, analysis

News in Brief

Ghana Civil Society to MPs: Don’t Leave Critical Transparency Provisions Out of Exploration and Production Bill

  • SOURCE: | qwesa2big
  • oil dollarTo further improve transparency in the oil and gas sector in Ghana, civil society organizations (CSOs) have
    recommended to the parliamentary Sub-Committee on Mines and Energy that lawmakers include explicit
    provisions on contracts and beneficial ownership disclosures in the long-awaited Petroleum (Exploration and
    Production) Bill, 2014 (E&P bill) before it is passed into law.

    At a stakeholders’ consultation meeting on the bill
    on 6 July, staff from the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI), Africa Centre for Energy Policy (ACEP),
    and Friends of the Nation (FoN), all lauded the introduction of certain provisions to ensure better transparency
    in the sector but expressed their concerns on the need for explicit provisions pertaining to contract and
    beneficial ownership disclosure.

    (The E&P Bill, when passed in law, will supersede the current Petroleum
    [Exploration and Production] Act, 1984 [PNDC Law 84])
    Ghana has progressed on the extractive transparency ladder since the 2007 discovery and 2010 production of
    crude oil. This is evidenced by the achievement of EITI compliant status in 2010, and the enactment of the
    Petroleum Revenue Management Act (2010) that requires quarterly and yearly reporting on petroleum
    revenue receipts and utilization. Yet, at the same time, there is not adequate effective transparency across the
    entire extractive decision chain, especially in the upstream sector: extractive data is still published in locked
    PDFs and JPEGs and is often quite old by the time it emerges.

    Oil contracts and their supplementary texts are
    not open to scrutiny, although some have been voluntarily publicized by the government. Licenses are mainly
    awarded through direct, negotiation without public tender processes, but even when licenses are awarded
    through competitive tendering processes, evaluation reports go unpublished.

    Yet multiple publications on
    international good practices suggest that adequate transparency and accountability in the extractive sector of a
    country is critical to ensure natural resource is managed effectively to the benefit of its citizens.
    While CSO staff commended the bill over the existing law with respect to the introduction of major
    transparency provisions such as competitive open bidding processes, they pushed for stronger provisions on
    contract transparency and beneficial ownership disclosure. The following are the key recommendations that
    were made by CSOs to the committee:
    Contract transparency
    Section 56 of the proposed bill requires the Petroleum Commission to maintain a register of petroleum
    agreements, licenses, permits and authorizations which should then be open to public. Although this is a major
    step towards contract transparency, CSOs argued that the current provision does not guarantee a complete
    publication of all forms of contracts and supplementary texts. Moreover, as currently stipulated, the provision
    is not explicit enough and could lead to multiple interpretations.

    Given that the citizens of Ghana are theowners of crude oil, contract transparency is crucial to increase their ability to analyze the government decisions to ensure maximum benefits for the state, check compliance of companies and government with the contracts, and also reduce potential corrupt practices in the sector. For instance, ACEP raised concerns over potential corruption that could emanate from the award of eight contracts in the sector due to lack of
    mandatory contract disclosure. CSOs strongly recommended that the contract disclosure provision should be
    explicit to include all forms of contracts, annexes, and supplementary as well as require timing and format for
    publication to prevent any further confusion.

    Disclosure of beneficial ownership Despite the heightened interest from civil society in the need for beneficial ownership disclosure in the petroleum sector, the draft bill does not include any provision on disclosure of who are the ultimate and true owners of petroleum companies. Due to the complex and often secretive ownership structures of extractive companies, they tend to develop improper and secret relationships with government officials as well as engage in illegal actions such as tax evasion, cronyism, and nepotism. Also, the complex ownership structures make it difficult to deter and prevent misconduct and crimes committed by extractive companies. CSOs strongly recommended that the bill include provisions for the mandatory disclosure of beneficial ownership of all

    ACEP’s Dr. Mohammed Amin cited examples of these companies and practices in Ghana and urged
    parliamentarians to consider mandatory disclosure of beneficial ownership as an anti-corruption tool in the bill.
    While investigating the questionable award of a contract to AGM Petroleum Ghana, ACEP found that the
    ownership structure of AGM is exceedingly complex and confusing: “AGM Petroleum Ghana is 100 percent
    owned by AGM Gibraltar, registered in a tax haven.

    AGR Energy, Minexco OGG and MED Songhai Developers
    own AGM Gibraltar. Minexco OGG is also registered in Gibraltar and is owned by Minexco Petroleum and WA
    Natural Resources, also registered in Gibraltar. Minexco Petroleum is owned by Minexco Group. On the other
    hand, AGR Energy is a subsidiary of AGR Group, which is also a subsidiary of Altor.
    Ghana’s EITI attempted beneficial ownership disclosure but could not gain adequate information on the true
    owners who exercise ultimate control of the companies that operate in Ghana. NRGI has been supporting the
    EITI multi-stakeholder group to improve on the search and disclosure of beneficial ownership information in its
    next EITI report.
    If these recommendations are considered by parliament and passed into law, Ghana could become a model for
    other countries in the region to follow.
    Samuel Bekoe is NRGI’s Africa regional associate.

    Leave a reply

    About Us
    Reporting Oil and Gas project was launched on 4th June 2009 at Takoradi, Western Region, Ghana by Penplusbytes ( with the vision of providing a one stop online information and knowledge about Ghana’s oil and gas sector read more
    Twitter Activity Stream

    Partners We are proud to be associated with:

    Skip to toolbar